If you have difficulty in submitting comments on draft standards you can use a commenting template and email it to admin.start@bsigroup.com. The commenting template can be found here.
Standards Development
This document defines terms and establishes a classification framework for academic, scientific, technological and skills competition events.
It covers competition events in which participants are primarily assessed on knowledge, research capability, scientific inquiry, technological application, engineering practice, innovation capability, professional or vocational skills, practical operation, problem-solving ability or competence-based performance.
This document provides classification criteria for such competition events, including purpose, subject area, participant group, organizational level, competition format, delivery mode, assessment method, outcome type, risk level and stakeholder involvement.
This document is applicable to stakeholders involved in the planning, organization, operation, evaluation, statistical analysis or improvement of academic, scientific, technological and skills competition events.
This document does not specify discipline-specific competition rules, scoring methods, technical requirements, qualification criteria, certification requirements or professional competence standards for any particular academic subject, scientific field, technological area or vocational skill. This document excludes sports competitions, cultural and artistic competitions, entertainment competitions and their specific technical, sporting or performance rules.
1 Market need and relevance
Academic, scientific, technological and skills competition events are widely organized at school, higher education, vocational education, professional, industry, national, regional and international levels. They support learning, talent development, scientific inquiry, technological innovation, vocational skills development, entrepreneurship, industry engagement and international exchange. Examples include academic Olympiad-type competitions, science and engineering fairs, programming competitions, robotics competitions, data and AI challenges, business case competitions, innovation and entrepreneurship competitions, and vocational skills competitions. Global competition activities are increasingly multi-level, cross-border, digital and hybrid. They involve diverse stakeholders and generate comparable data, results, awards, certificates, rankings and other outcomes. However, terminology and classification practices vary considerably among countries, education systems, industries and event organizers. The same activity may be described as a competition, contest, challenge, hackathon, fair, championship, case competition or skills competition, without a shared classification basis.
2 Problem to be addressed
The absence of a common vocabulary and classification framework creates difficulties for event organizers, public authorities, educational institutions, industry bodies, participants and international partners. It can hinder statistical comparison, stakeholder communication, event categorization, risk assessment, data management, quality improvement, recognition of outcomes and further development of related event management standards. It may also cause confusion between the proposed subject and sports competitions, cultural/artistic competitions, entertainment competitions, examinations, certification schemes and professional qualification systems.
3 Purpose of the proposed document
The purpose of this proposal is to establish a common language and a multi-dimensional classification framework for academic, scientific, technological and skills competition events. It will support consistent identification, description, communication, management, statistical analysis and international comparison of such events. It will also provide a foundation for future standards on management, fairness, transparency and integrity, assessment and judging, online and hybrid delivery, data management, intellectual property, participant safeguarding, accessibility, health and safety, sustainability and legacy of such competition events.
4 Why an International Standard
The subject is international by nature. Many competition events involve cross-border participation, international judging, online platforms, multinational teams, global rankings or internationally comparable awards. A globally agreed vocabulary and classification framework will help avoid fragmentation and enable cooperation among event organizers, educational institutions, industry associations, public authorities and standards bodies. The proposed proposal is aligned with the scope of ISO/TC 354, which includes standardization in the field of events, including competitions and academic purposes, as well as event-related terminology, data management, health, safety and security, accessibility, technology and sustainability.
5 Benefits
The document is expected to:
- provide a common vocabulary for event organizers and stakeholders;
- clarify the boundary between this field and sports, cultural/artistic, entertainment, examination and certification activities;
- support data collection, event classification and international comparison;
- enable better communication among organizers, participants, judges, education and training institutions, industry and public authorities;
- support the development of future event management standards for this type of competition event;
- promote fairness, transparency, inclusiveness and trust by making event types and classification criteria clearer.
6 Feasibility
The project is feasible because it focuses on common event terminology and classification, not on discipline-specific rules or technical scoring criteria. International practice is sufficiently mature across academic, scientific, technological, business and vocational skills competitions. The project can be developed using expert input from ISO/TC 354 members, liaison committees, education and training bodies, event organizers, industry associations, skills organizations and competition organizers.
7 Proposed working group
It is proposed that ISO/TC 354 establish a new Working Group: “Academic, scientific, technological and skills competition”. This WG would be responsible for this project and may subsequently consider related standards addressing management, fairness, transparency, integrity, judging, online/hybrid delivery and other aspects of such competition events.
You are now following this standard. Weekly digest emails will be sent to update you on the following activities:
You can manage your follow preferences from your Account. Please check your mailbox junk folder if you don't receive the weekly email.
You have successfully unsubscribed from weekly updates for this standard.
Comment on proposal
Required form fields are indicated by an asterisk (*) character.